Glossary

Explore Meshline

Products Pricing Blog Support Log In

Start with your goals.

Book a call
Autonomous Operations

Should MPP Opens Count Toward Your Klaviyo Engaged Segment? Decide, Then Rebuild It

Should Apple's automatic opens count as engagement in Klaviyo? See when excluding MPP opens is worth it and what you give up by doing so.

A smaller envelope icon overlapping a larger checklist icon.

Your engaged segment decides who gets your campaigns, win-backs and follow-ups.

If it counts opens that Apple's Mail Privacy Protection generated automatically, some of the people you treat as engaged may never have opened anything.

That is the decision in front of you: should MPP opens count toward engaged-segment membership, or should you rebuild the segment so only opens you can trust more qualify?

This article explains what the Apple Privacy Open flag in Klaviyo actually tells you.

It also shows how to add the exclusion filter to an existing engaged segment.

Finally, it covers building a companion segment for people whose only recorded opens are MPP opens.

You will also see the tradeoff you accept when you exclude them, because the flag does not give you perfect information in either direction.

What an MPP open actually is

With iOS 15, macOS Monterey, watchOS 8 and iPadOS 15, Apple Mail users can turn on Mail Privacy Protection.

When a recipient has MPP on, all images in the messages they receive are preemptively loaded, whether the recipient opens the email or not.

Opens are tracked when a tracking pixel loads.

Because MPP pre-fetches that pixel, a false open event can be recorded in Klaviyo.

This artificially inflates open rates and makes it harder to identify subscribers who are truly engaged.

So an MPP open is not evidence that someone read your email.

It may be attributable to Apple's automation.

That is the core reason the question exists at all: if your engaged segment uses opens as a qualifying signal, MPP opens can qualify people who have not genuinely engaged.

What the Apple Privacy Open flag tells you

Opened Email events in Klaviyo can carry a property called Apple Privacy Open, which is either True or False.

The flag is available for Opened Email events occurring on or after November 20, 2021.

Opens before that release may not include this information in their metadata.

The two values mean different things, and neither gives you certainty:

  • True means the message was opened on a device with MPP turned on. The open event may be attributable to Apple's MPP and does not necessarily reflect a true email open. The message could have been opened by the inbox or by the recipient, and there is no way to differentiate between the two.
  • False means Klaviyo did not identify the event as an MPP open. This does not guarantee that a person opened and read the message either.

Keep both caveats in mind.

Excluding True opens removes opens you know may be automatic.

But a False flag is not proof of engagement, and older opens may lack the flag entirely.

One more wrinkle: a subscriber may have multiple inboxes for the same email address, such as Gmail and Apple Mail.

In that case, you may see both Apple Privacy opens and non-MPP open events for the same message.

How to decide whether to exclude MPP opens

This is your call as the sender, not a rule Klaviyo imposes.

The decision comes down to what you want the engaged segment to represent and what you are willing to lose.

Excluding MPP opens narrows the segment to signals you can trust more.

The cost is that MPP prevents you from knowing whether the excluded recipients actually read your emails.

A heavy Apple Mail audience could shrink noticeably once automatic opens stop counting, and some of those people may still be reading.

Three questions help you decide:

  • Does your engaged segment currently use Opened Email as a qualifying condition? If yes, MPP opens are inflating it and the exclusion filter applies directly. If your segment qualifies on clicks or purchases only, MPP opens are not affecting membership and this rebuild is not urgent.
  • Do you act on segment membership in ways that cost money or goodwill? If membership triggers paid sends, discounts or win-back offers, treating automatic opens as engagement is a targeting error you are paying for. If membership is only a reporting view, the stakes are lower.
  • Are you comfortable sending to people whose engagement you cannot verify? If yes, you can keep them in and accept the noise. If no, exclude the MPP opens and accept that some genuine readers may drop out of the segment.

If you decide to exclude, the next section shows the documented rebuild path.

If you decide not to exclude, you can still build the companion segment below to see who is in the ambiguous group before committing.

Rebuild the engaged segment with the exclusion filter

If your engaged segment follows Klaviyo's recommended structure, you can exclude MPP opens by adding the filter where Apple Privacy Open is false to the Opened Email criteria.

Here is the documented path in the segment builder:

  1. Navigate to Audience > Lists & segments.
  2. Open an existing segment and click Edit definition. To start a new segment, select Create > Segment and enter a name; if a naming panel opens, click Create segment to continue to the builder.
  3. Select What someone has done (or not done) > Opened Email, then choose how many opens and the time period to check.
  4. Click Add filter and select Apple Privacy Open.
  5. Choose is false to exclude MPP opens from this condition.
  6. Click Update segment for an existing segment, or Create segment for a new one, to save the definition.

To find profiles with recorded MPP opens instead, use Opened Email > at least once > over all time and add the filter Apple Privacy Open > is true.

Note what this segment includes and excludes.

It covers profiles with a recorded MPP open since tracking began.

It does not include people who enabled MPP yet have no recorded MPP opens.

A worked example of the rebuilt definition

Klaviyo's documented example segment includes all subscribers who have opened or clicked an email in the last 30 days, excluding MPP opens, or subscribed in the last 15 days.

The structure matters: the opened-or-clicked conditions form one group joined by OR, and the recent-subscription condition is a second path into the segment.

The important failure mode to understand: a profile with MPP opens can still qualify through a non-MPP open, a click, or a recent subscription.

The exclusion filter removes automatic opens from the Opened Email condition.

It does not remove everyone who has ever generated an MPP open.

If your intent is to keep people with any automatic opens out entirely, this filter alone will not do that.

You should verify the resulting membership before relying on it.

Connector logic matters here too.

In Klaviyo, conditions joined by AND make a segment more exclusive: every condition must be true for someone to qualify.

Conditions joined by OR make it more inclusive: someone must meet at least one of the joined conditions.

When you combine both, conditions joined by OR form a group, and a profile must meet every group joined by AND.

Build the companion segment for unengaged MPP openers

The exclusion filter answers who counts as engaged.

A second question follows: who has recorded MPP opens but no recent engagement you can verify?

Klaviyo documents a recipe for exactly this group.

Combine three conditions with AND, because every one must be true:

  • Opened Email > at least once > over all time, with Apple Privacy Open > is true.
  • Opened Email > zero times in your chosen time period, with Apple Privacy Open > is false.
  • Clicked Email > zero times in the same time period.

Choose a time period that fits how often you send, and use the same period for both the non-MPP open and click conditions.

The AND connector is what makes this work: since the last two conditions are negative, each must independently be true.

If you joined them with OR, someone who failed one condition but met the other would still qualify, which is the opposite of what you want.

Klaviyo suggests you consider excluding this segment from your campaign sends, while remembering that MPP prevents you from knowing whether these recipients read your emails.

That is a suggestion to weigh, not a mandate.

Some senders exclude the group; others keep sending and watch other signals such as clicks over a longer window.

Verify the result before you rely on it

After rebuilding, check the segment rather than assuming the filters did what you intended:

  • Confirm the Opened Email condition carries the Apple Privacy Open is false filter, not just a shorter time window.
  • Check whether the segment shrank, and by roughly what kind of membership, so you know how much of your audience was qualifying on automatic opens.
  • Spot-check a few profiles that left the segment and confirm their recent opens carry the True flag rather than a different disqualifying behavior.
  • Remember that opens before November 20, 2021 may not include the flag in their metadata, so very old open history is not fully classifiable.

Segments in Klaviyo are dynamic groups: most update in close to real time, and profiles move in and out based on whether their interactions match the conditions you set.

That means membership will keep shifting as people open, click and subscribe, so a one-time review is a snapshot, not a permanent verdict.

Where this fits in the rest of your automation

Once the engaged segment reflects opens you trust more, the next decisions usually live downstream.

Decide which flow emails should be tested against that audience.

Also decide whether the segment or a static list is the right container for a given send.

If your next step is flow logic, see Should You A/B Test That Flow Email in Klaviyo? Decide, Then Set It Up.

If you are weighing whether this engaged group should stay dynamic or be frozen for a campaign, see Active Segment or Static List? Decide Before You Build.

And if you are extending the same audience decision to a new channel, Should You Add SMS to Your Automation Flows? Decide Before You Build covers that choice.

The exclusion decision is ultimately a send-targeting tradeoff, not a data cleanup.

You are choosing which uncertainty to live with: opens that may be automatic, or an audience that omits readers you cannot verify.

Source references: help.klaviyo.com; help.klaviyo.com.

How Meshline can help. Connect automation, Organic Marketing (demand generation), and customer lifecycle management (Revenue Intelligence).

Bring topic planning, content publishing and performance feedback into the conversation about your workflow. Book a Meshline demo.

Revenue Intel

Ask us about this workflow.

Tell us what you want to fix or automate. We'll reply with the most useful next step.

See how we can help

Implementation decisions

Put this into practice

Before choosing a solution, define the problem, the available data and who will review the outcome.